Publication Ethics
THESARA follows the COPE Core Practices and the guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). This statement applies to authors, editors, reviewers, and the publisher.
Duties of Authors
- Submit original work that has not been published and is not under consideration elsewhere.
- Report research honestly and accurately, and provide data on request.
- Cite sources correctly and check the manuscript with Turnitin (similarity index at most 20%) before submission.
- List as authors only those who made a substantive contribution, and disclose funding and conflicts of interest.
- Meet research-ethics requirements and disclose the use of generative AI.
- Promptly notify the editor of significant errors in their work and cooperate in corrections or retractions.
Duties of Editors
- Evaluate manuscripts only on scientific quality, originality, and fit with the scope, regardless of the authors' race, gender, religion, citizenship, affiliation, or political views.
- Keep manuscripts and the identities of authors and reviewers confidential during double-anonymous review.
- Disclose conflicts of interest and withdraw from handling the related manuscript.
- Handle suspected misconduct following the COPE guidance and flowcharts.
- Publish corrections, clarifications, or retractions when needed.
Duties of Reviewers
- Give objective, constructive, and timely assessments; decline invitations outside their expertise or when they cannot meet the deadline.
- Keep manuscripts confidential and not use their information for personal advantage.
- Disclose conflicts of interest and not try to identify the authors.
- Tell the editor about substantial similarity with other work or suspected misconduct.
- Never upload manuscripts to unauthorised AI services.
Originality and Plagiarism
Every manuscript must meet standards of originality and correct attribution. Plagiarism, unacknowledged use of others' work, undisclosed duplicate publication, and misleading reworking or re-presentation of work are not permitted. See also the Plagiarism Policy.
Data Fabrication and Falsification
Authors must not fabricate data, manipulate results, misrepresent findings, or withhold information that affects interpretation. Where misconduct is suspected, the editor may request clarification or supporting documents and take proportionate action.
Authorship
Listed authors must have made a substantive scientific contribution, approved the final version, and accept responsibility for their contribution. Honorary authorship, omission of eligible authors, and authorship changes without the agreement of those involved are not permitted. Changes to the author list after submission require a reason and the agreement of all parties.
Conflicts of Interest
Authors, reviewers, and editors must disclose financial and non-financial interests that could influence the research or editorial decisions. Those with a conflict must withdraw from the related assessment. A conflict does not necessarily lead to rejection but must be managed transparently.
Research Ethics
Research involving humans, animals, personal data, or vulnerable groups must comply with applicable ethical requirements. Where ethics committee approval, research permits, or participant consent are required, authors must provide the relevant information. The journal may request supporting documents.
Use of Artificial Intelligence
The use of generative AI to produce or develop scientific content must be disclosed. AI tools cannot be listed as authors. Reviewers and editors must not upload confidential manuscripts to unauthorised AI services.
Publisher Responsibilities
Belajar Cerdas provides infrastructure, administrative and technical support, and document backups. The publisher must not force the acceptance of articles or change editorial decisions for commercial reasons.
Complaints, Appeals, and Alleged Misconduct
Authors may submit complaints or appeals through the journal's official email, describing the issue and relevant evidence. Complaints are handled by people without a conflict of interest, evaluated objectively following the COPE flowcharts, and documented. An appeal does not guarantee a changed decision but is considered fairly.
Corrections and Retractions
If errors are found after publication, the journal may publish a correction, an expression of editorial concern, or a retraction, according to the seriousness of the problem and the available evidence. Every post-publication action is explained transparently; articles are never removed merely to hide errors or misconduct.