Peer Review Process
THESARA uses double-anonymous (double-blind) peer review: authors and reviewers do not know each other's identities throughout the review. The manuscript sent to reviewers contains no author identities; author details are on the separate Title Page, which is not forwarded to reviewers, and reviewer identities are not disclosed to authors.
Stages
- Initial screening by the editor: scope, basic standards, administrative completeness, and a second similarity check with Turnitin (at most 20%).
- Assignment of at least two independent reviewers for manuscripts sent to review.
- Assessment of substance and methodology.
- Reviewer recommendation: accept, minor revision, major revision, or reject.
- Editorial decision.
- Revision and re-evaluation where needed.
The final decision rests with the responsible editor; reviewer recommendations inform, but do not automatically determine, the decision. When reviewers disagree substantially, the editor may seek clarification, appoint an additional reviewer, or carry out an independent evaluation.
Initial Selection and Desk Rejection
Manuscripts may be rejected at the initial stage if they fall outside the scope, fail basic standards of scholarly writing, have fundamental methodological problems, lack sufficient contribution, show signs of ethical misconduct, or remain administratively incomplete after a request to complete them. Rejections are communicated professionally and, where possible, with relevant reasons.
Revision
Authors must respond to reviewer comments systematically, with a response document explaining each change or the scientific reason a suggestion was not applied. The editor may return the manuscript for further review before the final decision.
Editorial Independence
Decisions to accept, reject, correct, or retract articles are based on scientific quality, academic integrity, and journal policy, never on payment, personal relationships, the author's academic rank, institutional affiliation, sponsor interests, or a target number of articles per issue. Articles written by editorial team members are handled by an independent editor without a conflict of interest.